Population Health

What to do when incarcerated patients need surgery

Surgical procedures for incarcerated people can be hard to come by and fraught with stressful dynamics. Get expert ethical advice.

| 2 Min Read

AMA News Wire

What to do when incarcerated patients need surgery

Apr 15, 2025

Roughly 2 million people in the U.S. are incarcerated and they often lack timely access to safe, effective surgical care. But this isn’t just a workforce issue. It’s also clinically and ethically relevant: Every stage of an incarcerated person's care needs to be put in the context of their restricted liberty, diminished legal agency and increased environmental risk for a range of abuses and trauma.

Membership brings great benefits

AMA membership offers unique access to savings and resources tailored to enrich the personal and professional lives of physicians, residents and medical students.

The April issue of AMA Journal of Ethics® (@JournalofEthics) explores the challenges facing heath professionals, health care organizations and governments in delivering clinically and ethically appropriate surgical care for incarcerees.

The AMA Journal of Ethics is an editorially independent, peer-reviewed journal devoted to helping students and clinicians navigate ethical decisions in service to patients and communities. The April issue of the journal includes the following articles.

  1. How Should Physicians Manage Traumatic Injuries Sustained During Incarceration?

    1. Patients’ rights to evidence-based standard of care should not be compromised for patients who are incarcerated.
  2. Care of Patients Who Are Incarcerated.”

    1. This article considers AMA Code of Medical Ethics’ opinions relevant to the care of patients who are incarcerated.
  3. How Should Surgeons Help Formerly Incarcerated Patients With Chronic Surgical Needs Maintain Care Continuity?

    1. Incarceration history adds to the clinical and ethical complexity of surgical care for patients who require an ostomy, especially when secondary to trauma.
  4. What Are the Top 5 Things Surgical Trainees Should Consider When Caring for Patients Who Are Incarcerated?

    1. The U.S. has the most individuals who are incarcerated worldwide.

Listen and learn

The journal’s April “Ethics Talk” podcast features a conversation with Cynthia Chandler, director of the Bay Area Legal Incubator, in Oakland, California, about the practice of sterilization in California state prisons. In addition, Anthony Loria, MD, a research resident in Rochester, New York, shares new research on surgical outcomes for incarcerated patients.

The April issue also features two author-interview podcasts. Listen to previous episodes of the “Ethics Talk” podcast or subscribe in iTunes or other services. 

Also, CME modules drawn from this month’s issue are collected at the AMA Ed Hub™ AMA Journal of Ethics webpage.

The next issue of the journal will focus on private equity in health care. Apply to be an AMA Journal of Ethics editorial fellow or senior editorial fellow and design a theme issue with us.

Subscribe to free AMA email newsletters

Get the latest news from the AMA on the topics that matter to you—delivered to your inbox.

General newsletter front door subscribe

FEATURED STORIES

Pharmacist speaks with customer

Physician-led care is best prescription for health of nation

| 5 Min Read
Reviewing data on a laptop

Turning data into action to strengthen physician well-being

| 7 Min Read
Doctor raising hand to ask a question in a seminar

Building physician leaders who guide with heart and skill

| 7 Min Read
Hand signing a contract

What doctors wish patients knew about end-of-life care planning

| 6 Min Read