With more than 120 physician specialties and subspecialties combined between the National Resident Matching Program’s Main Residency Match and the Specialties Matching Service, the options for what to pursue in residency and fellowship training are legion.
That’s why physicians who have both pursued and eschewed fellowship training advise that residents carefully weigh their choices before determining whether to enter practice or pursue further graduate medical education.
“I would encourage people to be very open to exploring things that they may have closed off during medical school,” said Dayna Isaacs, MD, MPH, a hematology/oncology fellow in Northern California. Dr. Isaacs is also a sectional delegate in the AMA Resident and Fellow Section. “In the transition of med school to residency, the lifestyles of these specialties really come to light as you assume that more graduated responsibility.”
Dr. Isaacs herself began residency training with the intent of becoming a hospitalist.
“I really enjoyed the rotations during medical school. But then when I got to residency, the lifestyle of being a hospitalist was not quite what I wanted,” she said. “We actually had an oncology inpatient rotation during internal medicine residency, and I really fell in love with the patient population. I really liked the level of critical thinking and detail that you get to do.”
As residents move through training, Dr. Isaacs and others who have been there talk about how they approached the decision about whether to pursue fellowship training—even if they ultimately chose not to do so.
Examine the specialty
Once you select a specialty for residency training, the decision-making isn’t necessarily done, said James Mossner, MD, MS, who is chief resident in a neurosurgery program in Chicago.
“Even if you have an idea of what you might want to do, you'll be surprised when you're actually in the throes of rounding or in the OR [operating room] or whatever it might be, and how different or validating it could be of an experience for you,” said Dr. Mossner, who also serves as a delegate for the AMA Resident and Fellow Section.
Dr. Mossner often advises residents to think about “making the medicine versus surgery decision,” which can sometimes be more of a “procedure” decision.
“We often tell people to think: Do you want to do something more procedural?” he said, while adding that the decision may not be as cut and dried as deciding between surgical and nonsurgical specialties. “That's not to say that if you do internal medicine, you can't do procedures. For example, gastroenterology and cardiology are very procedure-heavy.”
Another way to explore various fields of medicine is with the AMA “Shadow Me” Specialty Series, which offers advice directly from physicians about life in their specialties.
Examine your life goals
There are more factors to take into consideration—and the most important ones may not be related to your work. Jason Lesnick, MD, is an emergency physician at Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Nashville, Tennessee, who graduated from residency in 2020. In his role, he often advises emergency medicine residents about whether to take on fellowship training.
He said he asks them: “Can you only do the job you want with a fellowship?” If the answer is yes, he tells them, “Do the fellowship. Career satisfaction and longevity are important.”
Dr. Lesnick said his second question is about location.
“Is doing that fellowship the only way for you to get a job where you want?” he asks.
In choosing to move directly after residency training into full-time practice, Dr. Lesnick himself considered geography. At the time, he wanted to stay in the Houston area and begin building a life with his then-fiancée. As a recent chief resident at one of the larger emergency medicine programs in the city, he was confident he could secure an attending position in the area.
“The experience [of pursuing fellowship] is obviously an incredibly valuable opportunity,” Dr. Lesnick said. “The learning that could come from it, the mentorship and connections are very valuable. But, by having done residency in a big city and having worked with people in a large program already, I was looking at it in the sense that I already had those connections. So that aspect was less of a factor for me.”
Vanderbilt University Medical Center is a member of the AMA GME Competency Education Program, which helps institutions meet the ACGME Common Program Requirements through flexible, on-demand micro learning modules for residents. The program fits into demanding clinical schedules and is supported by streamlined reporting tools for program administrators. Learn more.
Examine your finances
With research organization the Education Data Initiative showing that physicians graduated from medical school in 2026 with an average of $257,514 in combined loan debt from medical school and undergraduate education, physicians may need to consider their finances before making decisions about fellowship training.
“Loans feel like hundreds of thousands of little weights you carry around with you,” Dr. Lesnick said. “There’s pressure, I feel, to get that done with as soon as possible.”
Additionally, he said, there is an opportunity cost.
“If you invested $100,000 your first year out as an attending in an S&P 500 index fund, that money would on average compound to be about a million dollars by the end of your career,” he said. “It is very unlikely you could do that as a fellow.”
AMA members can schedule a free 30-minute session with a student loan expert at KeyBank to explore student loan repayment or forgiveness options. KeyBank is one of the nation’s largest full-service banks, offering banking, lending and student loan solutions for physicians at every stage of their careers.
When considering your financial plan for residency and beyond, KeyBank offers special AMA member rates on student-loan refinancing, home loans and practice financing.
Examine your plan
Once you’ve found a subspecialty you think you’d like to pursue in fellowship training, seek additional opportunities in it, advised Dr. Isaacs.
“I was first exposed to oncology in the inpatient setting. But oncology is very different in the clinic setting than in the inpatient setting, so I made sure to request additional oncology rotations so that I could rotate through the clinic setting and see what the day-to-day actually looks like,” she said.
That also helped her develop connections.
“Obviously, you're seeing patients and you're clinically doing those rotations, but you're exposed to mentors and fellows who you can ask questions one-on-one about why they chose it,” she said.
Dr. Mossner also suggested getting involved with research in the field—even if you’re not 100% certain in your decision.
“By the time you get around to applying—let's say you were in family medicine all the way up until your third year and then you decided you wanted to do neurosurgery, but you don't have any research—it's going to be very hard for you without taking a gap year. Even taking a gap year, it's going be very difficult to get the CV that you will need for a very competitive specialty,” he said. “Whereas, if you thought you were going into one of the more competitive specialties and you're like, I really like psychiatry, well, then you have an amazing CV to help pick wherever you want to go in the country.”
No matter what you decide, don’t shortchange the process. You might be surprised during training by a change of heart. And you must be true to yourself.
“It's never too late, I think, to make the jump to fellowship, because it really is the rest of your career in medicine,” Dr. Isaacs said. “It is a big decision to make about where you'll be the happiest.”
Find out more about the AMA Resident and Fellow Section, which gives voice to—and advocates on—issues that affect resident and fellow physicians.
—Senior News Writer Brendan Murphy contributed to this report.