Oct. 30, 2026: Judicial Advocacy Update

| 6 Min Read

Federal court strikes down restrictions on Medicaid medical frailty exemptions

On Oct. 29, the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts ruled in Massachusetts v. Oz that CMS exceeded its statutory authority by narrowing the medical frailty exemption from Medicaid work requirements established under H.R. 1, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. The court vacated the narrowed definition nationwide and permanently enjoined its enforcement against the plaintiff states.

General email newsletter lean icon
Haven't subscribed?
Stay current on the latest issues impacting physicians, patients and healthcare with the AMA’s Advocacy Update newsletter.

“Today’s decision is a victory for patients as it strikes back against unnecessary barriers to care,” said AMA President Willie Underwood III, MD, MSc, MPH, in an AMA press statement. “The court rightly rejected a federal restriction that would have made it harder for people with serious or complex health conditions to qualify for an exemption from Medicaid work requirements. Patients should not have to clear unnecessary bureaucratic hurdles to keep their health coverage, especially hurdles that go beyond what Congress intended. The AMA will continue fighting to protect access to medically necessary care and ensure bureaucratic red tape doesn’t stand in patients’ way.”

Under H.R. 1, individuals who are medically frail, including those with substance use disorders, disabling mental disorders, physical, intellectual, or developmental disabilities, or serious or complex medical conditions, are expressly excluded from Medicaid work requirements. However, a CMS interim final rule issued in June required individuals to demonstrate not only that they have a qualifying condition, but also that their medical conditions “significantly impair” their ability to comply with work requirements. The court concluded that CMS exceeded its authority by imposing this additional restriction on the exemption established by Congress.

On Sept. 10, the AMA, the Massachusetts Medical Society, and nine national medical specialty societies filed an amicus brief (PDF) supporting the challenge to the CMS rule. The brief argued that CMS unlawfully narrowed the medical frailty exemption established by Congress, creating unnecessary administrative barriers that could cause eligible patients to lose Medicaid coverage. The AMA and Massachusetts Medical Society also filed an earlier amicus brief (PDF) on July 21 supporting the states' request for a preliminary injunction.

Although the court struck down CMS's narrowed definition of medical frailty, other provisions of the rule remain in place, including restrictions on states' ability to accept self-attestation and limitations on the use of claims and encounter data older than 12 months to identify individuals who qualify for an exemption.

The AMA will continue working with state medical associations and policymakers to promote implementation approaches that protect eligible patients from unnecessary coverage losses, minimize administrative burdens on physicians and patients, and preserve access to medically necessary care. 

Physician organizations file amicus brief supporting challenge to Medicaid work rule

The AMA, joined by the Maryland State Medical Society (MedChi) and several national physician organizations, filed an amicus brief (PDF) in Taylor v. Kennedy supporting plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment in a challenge to federal Medicaid work requirement regulations. Filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland, the brief argues that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) exceeded its statutory authority by narrowing the medical frailty exemption established by Congress. The physician organizations contend that the rule unlawfully adds a requirement not found in the statute by requiring individuals with qualifying medical conditions to prove that those conditions “significantly impair” their ability to comply with work requirements. 

According to the brief, Congress expressly excluded medically frail individuals from Medicaid work requirements under H.R. 1, including people with substance use disorders and those with serious or complex medical conditions. The amici argue that CMS cannot rewrite that protection by converting it from a medical-status exemption into an ability-to-work test. The brief also opposes CMS restrictions on states’ ability to accept self-attestation of medical frailty. The physician organizations argue that those limits will increase paperwork burdens, make it harder for eligible patients to maintain coverage, and create avoidable barriers to care. 

“People living with serious or complex medical conditions should not lose their health coverage because of unnecessary administrative barriers,” AMA President Willie Underwood III, MD, MSc, MPH, said in an AMA press release. “Losing Medicaid coverage can mean losing access to essential medications, interrupting ongoing treatment, and putting patients’ health at risk.” 

The amici emphasize that Medicaid expansion provides a critical source of coverage for about 20 million Americans. The brief cites research linking Medicaid expansion to improved access to care and lower mortality among patients with serious conditions, including cancer, cardiovascular disease, opioid use disorder, and liver disease. It warns that unnecessary coverage disruptions could undermine those gains and place vulnerable patients at greater risk.  

The filing also highlights the practical burden the CMS rule could place on physicians. Because Medicaid claims and encounter data often document diagnoses and treatment, but not a patient’s functional ability to satisfy work requirements, the rule could force treating physicians to make high-stakes eligibility assessments without clear standards or validated criteria. The brief argues that this added administrative work would divert time and resources away from patient care and could strain the patient-physician relationship. 

This amicus brief also follows the AMA’s earlier amicus advocacy in a separate challenge to the same Medicaid work requirements rule. As described in a prior Advocacy Update, the AMA and the Massachusetts Medical Society filed an amicus brief (PDF) in July supporting 25 states’ and the District of Columbia’s request for a preliminary injunction in Massachusetts v. Oz, and in September, the AMA, the Massachusetts Medical Society, and nine national medical specialty societies filed a second amicus brief (PDF) supporting the plaintiff states in their motion for summary judgment. Those briefs likewise argued that CMS exceeded its authority by narrowing the medical frailty standard and restricting states’ use of self-attestation, creating unnecessary administrative burdens, and increasing the risk that eligible patients would lose coverage for procedural reasons. On Oct. 29, the court granted summary judgment to the plaintiff states on their challenge to CMS’s narrowed definition of medical frailty, vacating that provision nationwide and permanently enjoining its enforcement against the plaintiff states. The court upheld the rule’s restrictions on self-attestation and 12-month lookback period for use of claims and encounter data.

In addition to the AMA and MedChi, the brief in Taylor v. Kennedy was joined by the American Academy of Family Physicians, American Academy of Hospice and Palliative Medicine, American College of Emergency Physicians, American College of Obstetricians & Gynecologists, American Society of Addiction Medicine, Association for Clinical Oncology, and American Thoracic Society. In Taylor v. Kennedy, the organizations similarly ask the court to grant plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment and vacate the challenged provisions of the rule, including the narrowed definition of medical frailty and the limits on use of self-attestation.

Standing for physicians
The AMA Litigation Center is the strongest voice for America's medical profession in legal proceedings across the country.

FEATURED STORIES

Man power walking or jogging, with dumbbells

New changes expand diabetes-prevention for more Medicare patients

| 3 Min Read
Three healthcare workers in discussion

AMA Joy in Medicine points the way to better care

| 5 Min Read
Doctors hold up magnifying glasses over a giant pancreas

Beyond watch and wait: Taking aim at pancreatic cysts

| 7 Min Read
Philip Kuriakose, MD, featured on "Health vs. Hype" AMA podcast

5 things patients should know about microplastics

| 8 Min Read