Judicial Advocacy

Patient privacy court ruling would interfere with care

| 1 Min Read

Physicians are petitioning a state supreme court to hear a previously decided case that holds patient care in the balance by making patients’ personal prescription data too widely available. 

Scales of Justice on wooden table, courtroom blurred in the background

In Lewis v. Superior Court (Medical Board of California), a lower court ruling grants law enforcement and other government employees broad access to the state’s prescription drug monitoring program’s database. Physicians are flagging the ruling as a violation of confidentiality in the physician-patient relationship.

“The duty of physicians to protect patient privacy lies at the very core of the medical profession,” the Litigation Center of the AMA and State Medical Societies and the California Medical Association stated in a petition submitted to the California Supreme Court last week.

“Confidentiality is one of the most enduring ethical tenets in the practice of medicine, and is essential to the patient-physician relationship,” the petition continues. “It is the cornerstone of the patient’s trust [and is key to] successful medical information gathering for accurate diagnosis and treatment, an effective physician-patient relationship, good medicine and quality care.”

The petition also points to the importance of this case because it deals both with fundamental elements of patient care and with the issue of personal privacy in the digital era. 

FEATURED STORIES

Woman handing an insurance card to a doctor who is reviewing paperwork

AMA report: Health insurance giants tighten grip on U.S. markets

Dec 16, 2025
Patients in a waiting room at a doctor's office

What to expect from the 2026 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule

| 7 Min Read
Row of blocks with businesspeople with one being taken away

4 “Big, Beautiful Bill” changes that will reshape care in 2026

| 6 Min Read
Wood poles with question mark symbols

PAs push to enshrine “physician associate” term in law

| 6 Min Read