At the end of residency or fellowship training, physicians will be well-prepared to practice medicine in their chosen specialty. They may feel less ready, however, to untangle the knotty topic of payments to physicians from Medicare and Medicaid, the nation’s largest healthcare insurers.
Nearly all physicians in all specialties will care for beneficiaries of one or both of these public health insurance providers. Data from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) shows that, as of May, 70.5 million people in the U.S. were enrolled in some form of Medicare. Meanwhile, 66.4 million people were enrolled in Medicaid and the related Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP).
Medicare is a federal program that is the same in all 50 states, while Medicaid is a joint federal-state program that varies widely throughout the country.
There are some generalizations that can be made about physician payment in both insurers, however. Read more here about the basics of Medicare and Medicaid.
What follows are important nuances about payments to physicians from both payers, as well as potential trouble spots to sidestep, for all residents and fellows preparing to enter practice.
Medicare payments require setup
When it comes to getting paid under Medicare, physicians in the transition to practice face several bureaucratic tasks. First, you must choose whether to participate in Medicare. If you are a nonparticipating physician, you will get paid less, but you can still bill Medicare and you can charge patients more than the Medicare payment amount. And even participating physicians are not required to accept new patients with Medicare.
Opting out of Medicare entirely is a formal, legal process that usually lasts for two years and automatically renews until cancellation. If you opt out, you will need to create separate payment contracts with patients who have Medicare.
The process of billing Medicare requires enrollment, and physicians also should understand whether they will be reassigning their benefits to a group that will then accept payment on their behalf. If you will be an employed physician, your new employer should guide you through the reassignment process. Medicare also requires direct deposit for payments, another process that must be set up by you or your employer. The AMA offers resources for getting a private practice up and running.
You will document and code your healthcare services just as you did in residency and fellowship training. Claims must be submitted to the regional Medicare Administrative Contractor within a year of the date of service.
From CEO skills to entrepreneurship to independent practice, the AMA helps physicians get ahead. Learn more about the new AMA Career Advancement Collective, a powerful suite of educational programs and training to help physicians develop and advance at every stage of their career.
Medicaid payments situation more variable
When it comes to Medicaid payments for physicians, the answer to almost any question is “it depends on the state.” Though the federal government pays for a percentage of states’ Medicaid costs, the program is administered by states within loose federal guidelines. Therefore, details such as how and when physicians are paid under Medicaid also vary widely from state to state.
Most Medicaid recipients are in managed-care organizations, which are private health insurance companies contracted by the state to oversee coverage. States are also allowed to provide Medicaid coverage through a fee-for-service model.
To learn specific information about how Medicaid is administered in your state, visit the federal Medicaid benefits website, and select the state where you practice in the “state Medicaid and CHIP profiles” dropdown menu.
Learn more about the different types of healthcare payment models with the AMA STEPS Forward® toolkit, “Physician Payment Models Guide.” It is enduring material and designated by the AMA for a maximum of 0.5 AMA PRA Category 1 Credit™. Read up on AMA CME accreditation.
Where these insurers will not pay
In some cases, Medicare and Medicaid are not allowed to pay the costs related to treatment. For example, Medicare will not pay for:
- Most cosmetic surgeries or elective procedures.
- Treatment and devices determined to be medically unnecessary or investigational.
- Most overseas or foreign medical care.
- Routine dental, foot, hearing or vision care.
- Long-term custodial care.
The Medicare website allows you to search whether a given item, test or service is nationally covered under the program. Conditions in those categories that Medicaid will not cover may also vary by state.
Dual eligibility in physician payments
It’s possible for patients to qualify for, and have, health insurance coverage through both Medicare and Medicaid. Those patients are called “dual-eligible beneficiaries” or “duals.” When someone is considered dual eligible, they qualify for the full benefits provided by Medicare. But their income and assets may determine the level of benefits they qualify for under Medicaid in their state.
There are multiple categories of dual-eligible recipients, many of which are based on the recipient’s income and resources. There are “partial duals,” who qualify for some additional benefits under Medicaid—such as some Medicare premiums or cost-sharing expenses—and “full duals,” who also receive Medicaid benefits for some of the services that Medicare does not cover, such as long-term care.
In most cases, physicians or healthcare organizations will first bill Medicare when the service or treatment is covered. Medicaid might then pay for some or all of the remainder.
It is important to know that federal law prohibits physicians or healthcare organizations from billing patients determined to be a “Qualified Medicare Beneficiary” (QMB) for any of their Medicare cost-sharing expenses related to a service covered by parts A or B, even if their state’s Medicaid program limits reimbursement for or does not reimburse those costs. This is true whether the physician participates in Medicare, whether the physician is enrolled in Medicaid in that state and whether the patient has gotten care across state lines.
A physician or healthcare organization that improperly bills a QMB can be sanctioned, so it is vital to understand your patient’s status before billing. You can use a system available on the CMS website to determine the Medicare beneficiary eligibility status of patients.
Advocacy is key with payments
The Medicare Physician Fee Schedule, set by the federal government, heavily influences the amount of money physicians get from other payers, as well. Commercial healthcare insurance companies typically anchor their payment rates to the Medicare fee schedule, and Medicare payments or relative value units (RVUs) are often used in physician compensation systems.
And problems with physician payment have plagued Medicare for years, with Medicare physician payment failing to keep up with the cost of practicing medicine in the U.S. In the last 25 years, after adjusting for inflation, Medicare physician payment fell by 33%.
Read more about the AMA’s work to gain passage for The Patients First Act of 2026 (H.R. 9693), and visit AMA Advocacy in Action to find out what’s at stake in reforming Medicare payment and other advocacy priorities the AMA is actively working on.