There is an old axiom in real estate: Location, location, location. It means a property’s site is the most important driver of value.
There is a similar one in physician-employment contracting, or at least there ought to be: Terms, terms, terms. That’s because the terms of an employment contract determine whether your agreed-upon compensation is real and even whether you can resign if you want or need to. These are elements that all physicians should consider carefully, whether they are signing their first physician-employment agreement or are further along in their medical careers.
“Things like: Do I have a noncompete? Things like: What is my call coverage requirement? All of these things are bringing value that's not necessarily monetary but it's going to have real impact on what you're willing to accept,” said Kyle Claussen, CEO of Resolve, a contract review and negotiation firm specializing in physician employment, in a webinar on physician salary and contract trends.
Claussen outlined a dozen terms that deserve special scrutiny in employment contract review, broken into two groups: what happens day to day in the job and what happens when you leave it.
The AMA has teamed up with Resolve to provide AMA members an exclusive discount on services that include custom contract review. Resolve offers personalized legal expertise to help physicians secure the best employment contract terms, no matter where they are in their careers. Ready to access your AMA-member Resolve discount? Learn more now.
How who you work for affects risk
For many, the term “employed physician” conjures images of working for a hospital, and while it’s true that the share of doctors in private practice is smaller than it has ever been, many physicians are of course employed by a private practice. Both options have their pros and cons.
“You usually are going to see, as a general rule, higher guarantees in an employed setting. You’re going to see more robust benefit packages in an employed setting,” Claussen said, adding that while the recruitment packages may be less aggressive at private practices, “you've got almost unlimited upside—the ability to become a partner, the ability to own ancillary revenues.”
Similarly, hospital or health system jobs usually offer less autonomy than private-practice jobs, but they also often have lower production metrics.
It is important, then, to know what you most want out of your job and to accept only those tradeoffs. What you don’t want to do, Claussen said, is to be left with neither of the financial advantages, “a situation where you're not getting much guaranteed and there's also no upside.”
From CEO skills to entrepreneurship to independent practice, the AMA helps physicians get ahead. Learn about the new AMA Career Advancement Collective, a powerful suite of educational programs and training to help physicians develop and advance at every stage of their career.
Group 1: Schedule and duties
Claussen cited two specific areas where risk lives in a contract. The first has to do with where you are going to work and the work you are going to do.
“All of these things are usually why the clients that we talk to either burn out, become dissatisfied, whatever word you want to use,” he said. “It's usually not compensation based. It’s usually something to do with the job day in and day out. And so we think that more detail in these areas really is an increased value.”
He advised paying particular attention to the following contract terms:
- Location(s) of the practice.
- Days of the week and time allocations.
- Call expectations.
- Supervision of nonphysician providers.
- Outside activities and intellectual property.
- Administrative and research time.
A blog post on the Resolve website explains how vagueness in some of these terms can effectively erase limits on your workload.
"When first looking at a job, aspects like scheduling, call hours and work locations can appear straightforward,” it says. “You might expect to always be working in the facility you first toured, and working hours are often verbally promised many times over.
“However, employers can quickly change their minds, and if your contract doesn’t include the right protections, you might find yourself picking up extra shifts, covering additional call hours or traveling to multiple clinics.”
Group 2: Termination
“The other side of the coin that has value that's not monetary … is all of your termination provisions,” Claussen said, citing the following crucial contract terms:
- Notice periods and how notice is delivered.
- For-cause triggers.
- Tail coverage.
- Payment of earned production bonus.
- Noncompetes and repayment obligations.
- Liquidated damages and access to records.
Here too, the blog post provides an example of what’s at stake.
“You might expect leaving a job to always be an option, provided you give some notice and follow other expectations before making your exit. But surprisingly, not all contracts provide a clear way to terminate your employment,” it says.
“Any contract should have a termination ‘without cause’ section, which normally allows either you or your employer to terminate the agreement after a specified notice period—often 90 days. While a way to end the contract seems like an obvious inclusion, employers sometimes leave it out or make it one-sided, so they can let you go but you cannot leave on your own accord.
“The absence of termination terms can trap you in a job that you no longer want. Without these terms defined, the only way out could be to negotiate some sort of release with your employer or breach the contract and deal with potential financial consequences.”
A report on physician salary data (email required) recently released by Resolve goes in depth on the state of physician compensation. It includes analysis of current trends in productivity, workload, and call expectations and features a section decoding fine print, “Contract Terms Physicians Don't Expect (But Should).”
AMA members receive a 20% discount on all Resolve services. With Resolve, you get:
- Custom contract review for any type of employment contract.
- Access to experienced attorneys who can negotiate on your behalf.
- Real-time, comprehensive compensation data and benchmarks to help you understand your worth.
- An instant contract-review option, powered by Resolve’s attorney-trained AI model.
- Free tools such as a contract scorecard to give a quick overview of where your contract stands.
Ready to access your AMA-member Resolve discount? Learn more now.