How to build a list of target residency programs for Match success

The path to residency starts homing in on the right programs. Learn how to create a balanced list of options that aligns with your ambitions.

By
Brendan Murphy Senior News Writer
| 6 Min Read

Physician residency applicants have options. Depending on the physician specialty being pursued, there might be several hundred residency programs to which a future physician can apply. 

The first step to a successful Match is homing in on the residency programs to which one plans to apply. A thoughtful list of target programs should be tailored to a residency applicant’s specialty ambitions while considering competitiveness and other individualized circumstances.

Search FREIDA™ for a residency or fellowship
Get access to the member-only residency guide, calculator and dashboard where you can save, compare and rank programs.

For the 2026–2027 Match cycle, application submissions in the Electronic Residency Service (ERAS) platform open Sept. 2, and programs can begin accessing applications Sept. 23. In advance of those dates, these expert tips highlight key considerations for creating a stronger, smarter residency-application strategy.

Know the landscape for a specialty

Looking at data from the most recent residency-application cycle—compiled by the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC)—both total applications and the average number of applications per applicant were down in 2026. 

The list of physician specialties in which the average number of residency applications was highest in the most recent cycle included integrated plastic surgery (an average of 68 applications for senior applicants from MD-granting medical schools), neurological surgery (62) and diagnostic radiology (57). All of those fields are among the most competitive for applicants annually. 

Wayne Bond Lau, MD, is a dean for student affairs at Thomas Jefferson University's Sidney Kimmel Medical College in Philadelphia. He frequently works with applicants throughout the Match process. 

“Residency program availability is not the same for different specialties,” said Dr. Lau, an AMA member. “For example, there are far more internal medicine or pediatric programs in the country than compared to, for example, orthopedic surgery or ophthalmology programs. There is a supply and demand situation.”

“If someone is applying to a very competitive residency, which does not offer many interview spots, even the most competitive applicants are going to likely need to submit a good number of applications.”

Jefferson Health, which is the home of Sidney Kimmel Medical College, is part of the AMA Health System Member Program that provides enterprise solutions to equip leadership, physicians and care teams with resources to help drive the future of medicine.

Get residency-ready with AMA benefits
Find your perfect match using full features of FREIDA™, the AMA Residency & Fellowship Database®. Distinguish yourself with AMA leadership opportunities.

Assess your standing

The medical student-specific part of finding the application total sweet spot is going to be unique to one’s individual profile. A highly competitive residency applicant may be able to apply to fewer programs, while a less competitive applicant may need to cast a wider net, even in a less competitive specialty.

To understand how competitive one’s applicant profile is, Dr. Lau recommended an assessment of academic performance, an applicant’s U.S. Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) Step 2 score, letters of recommendation and rotation feedback. These are among the key factors that residency programs consider in determining which applicants to invite for interviews

“The biggest mistake that I have seen is when students don't honestly appraise their competitiveness well,” Dr. Lau said. “Students either believe that they're less competitive than they are, and they lack confidence.  There are also students that believe that they are much more competitive than they actually are, and an honest conversation needs to be had.”

As applicants embark on the residency application process, they should consult FREIDA™, the AMA Residency and Fellowship Database®, which is a comprehensive resource that includes information on more than 14,000 Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education-accredited residency programs and offers a streamlined user experience. 

Get feedback on your residency program list

Dr. Lau stressed that medical students should not build a residency application list in isolation. Because competitiveness varies by specialty, program reputation, geography and an applicant’s own record, it is essential to get candid feedback from people who understand both the student and the field.

“It’s very important for any student to have a deep conversation with their student affairs advisory dean and also with a specialty adviser,” Dr. Lau said. “A specialty adviser is likely a practicing physician in that given field and knows that landscape intimately, with specific program knowledge as well.”

“Through consultation with the specialty adviser and their deans, those students should be able to create lists based on their academic performance and their Step 2 score to begin stratifying programs of competitive interest.”

Advisers can also look at aspects of a residency application that go beyond test scores and evaluate if they might help augment weaker parts of an application. 

The AMA Road to Residency Guide
Plan your path to residency, from researching programs and excelling at interviews to navigating Match Day and beyond.

Apply in buckets

Applying to programs across the spectrum of competitiveness is a prudent approach, Dr. Lau said. One effective tactic for many medical students is to break their application list into three buckets—reach programs, target, and the most realistic programs. 

The first draft program list might start with one-third of programs in each group. From there, “adjustments must be made based upon individual accomplishments, objective metrics, and your specialty advisers’ recommendations about certain programs,” Dr. Lau said. “Such an approach will help tailor the ideal residency application list to be the right mix.” 

He added that aiming high—especially if an applicant has an impressive track record of extracurricular involvement in activities such as research and community service—is an acceptable approach as long as doing so is balanced with targeting other, less competitive residency programs. 

“I support students that apply for reach and dream programs, as long as the application list contains programs that are balanced in terms of competitiveness,” Dr. Lau said. “You only have one chance to go through medical school.”

Cross-applying can make sense

In the 2026 residency-selection cycle, 42% of applicants applied to more than one specialty, according to the latest figures from the AAMC. 

In some instances, residency applicants may be torn between two physician specialties. In others, the decision to cross apply may be driven by competition. 

“If your dream specialty is one where you might not be the most competitive, it can be advisable to have a backup plan,” Dr. Lau said.

If you dual apply, one must ensure "they would be happy practicing in either field," Lau said. If that’s the case, it can definitely increase Match odds. 

Dr. Lau added that the approach comes with some risks. Certain specialties or programs may question an applicant’s commitment if they find out they are a dual applicant. It also is likely to increase residency application expenses. 

“If you dual apply, there are important considerations, and it can be a delicate road,” Dr. Lau said. “Students [who dual apply] should absolutely do this in close consultation with their mentors and advisers.”

AMA members get more from FREIDA for residency search

MORE RESOURCES

FREIDA AMA residency guide

Dig deeper in the FREIDA™ Road to Residency Guide

2026 Match Week

Navigate Match Week and beyond

Person looking up at question marks

Understand residency match slang with this glossary

Newsletter icons: Road to Residency

Subscribe to the Road to Residency newsletter