Figure - Do Readers and Peer Reviewers Agree on Manuscript Quality?
Summary quality grades by judge type. Test of differences between
experts and readers, experts and peers, and readers and peers, after
grades were dichotomized as "acceptable" (>/=5) or "not
acceptable" (</=4): chi2(1)=41.7 (P<.001), 16.8
(P<.001), and 3.4 (P >.5), respectively.
Return to article
