Advertisement
AlertSubscribe to Email Alert
American Medical News

American Medical News

 
HEALTH

Teens to be the target of pertussis boosters

More frequent outbreaks of the disease are leading to heightened awareness and are raising concerns in the public health community.

By Susan J. Landers, amednews staff. Oct. 6, 2003. - Clarification

  • PRINT|
  • E-MAIL|
  • RESPOND|
  • REPRINTS|
  • Share SHARE Share
  •  

Washington -- Pertussis is believed by many to be a disease of young children. However, sometimes a lengthy bout of a severe, hacking cough in an adolescent or adult patient should trigger suspicion, too.

It's a critical awareness for primary care physicians because the consequences of missing a pertussis diagnosis could be serious, even fatal, for unvaccinated infants who come in contact with these individuals.

"We in peds tend to think about pertussis, but I don't think the adult folks do. I think there is probably a lot of underdiagnosis going on in family practitioner and internal medicine offices," said Margaret Rennels, MD, professor of pediatrics at the University of Maryland Medical School.

Vaccine schedules call for the first shot of the DTaP vaccine series to be given to infants when they are 2 months old with the fifth, final dose generally administered by age 6 years.

Although adolescents and adults who develop pertussis are more likely to get a milder disease, the hazard is that they are the parents, uncles and aunts of infants and could transmit the disease.

"So although it doesn't mean too much to the adolescents and adults in terms of illness, in terms of public health they are important because they turn out to be the spreaders, and they bring it home," said William Schaffner, MD, chair of the Dept. of Preventive Medicine at Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, Tenn.

Pertussis vaccine boosters for adolescents are being developed.

There is still some debate over whether there is a real increase in pertussis or whether it is a matter of the disease being better recognized and diagnosed, noted Rennels. "But the current thought is that it is probably real."

Pertussis outbreaks are not unusual, said Kris Bisgard, DVM, MPH, a medical epidemiologist at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The outbreaks occur when there are enough susceptible people -- something that happens naturally because the i mmunity imparted by the vaccine wanes over time.

"Even in the best of circumstances, like after the fourth dose is given, the vaccine is only about 85% effective against severe pertussis," said Dr. Bisgard. However, it is generally recognized that the vaccine does protect against death and that fully vaccinated children are well-protected. (See clarification.)

The way the body develops and expresses the vaccine's protection against pertussis is not completely understood, said Dr. Schaffner. "For other vaccines we know exactly what to measure in the blood stream that correlates with immunity; for pertussis we are still trying to figure that out."

Pertussis boosters

The fact that the vaccine has to fight a bacterial infection seems to make pertussis a more formidable opponent than a virus-caused disease like measles, said Dr. Bisgard.

The CDC's Epidemic Intelligence Service recently investigated a pertussis outbreak in South Carolina. There was some thought that the outbreak was caused by a new strain of pertussis, but that proved not to be the case, at least so far.

Meanwhile, a booster shot for pertussis is likely in the near future for adolescents. Although a suitable vaccine for this older age group is not yet licensed, a couple are in the works, said Dr. Rennels. "When they are licensed, I wouldn't be surprise d if a booster is recommended," she said.

Aventis Pasteur expects to submit its adolescent and adult version of the acellular pertussis vaccine to the Food and Drug Administration for approval soon with a likely approval by 2005, said Michael Decker, MD, MPH, vice president for scientific and medical affairs at Aventis.

Dr. Decker expects the vaccine to first target 12-year-olds because their original vaccinations, at age 6, are likely wearing off.

If the United States does move toward pertussis boosters, it will be a road already taken by Canadians. In August, the Canadian Pediatric Society recommended that all provinces provide a booster shot of acellular pertussis vaccine to adolescents. So fa r, only a few provinces and the Northwest Territories routinely administer the boosters.

Although the Canadian health system doesn't yet cover the cost of the boosters, the pediatric society is recommending that physicians discuss the risks and benefits of the vaccine with adolescents and their parents so they may make an informed decision about whether to pay for the shots themselves.

Back to top


 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION: 

Not just for kids

Bordetella pertussis can infect adolescents and adults and may be indistinguishable from other upper respiratory infections. The disease:

  • Accounts for up to 7% of cough illnesses among this population per year.
  • Is often milder than when seen in infants and children.
  • Can be transmitted to infants.

Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

Back to top


Immunization: Cost-effective?

Vaccinating 80% of adolescents in the United States would cost $75 million, but would save $70 million, according to a poster presented at the Interscience Conference on Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy in Chicago last month.

Researchers lead by Caro Research, an independent consulting group in Boston, used the Markov model to analyze the economic impact of the cost of giving the shot to teenagers and the benefit that could be gained from herd immunity. Data was gathered fr om government and private databases, and, in some cases, estimated by experts with the Global Pertussis Initiative.

Researchers found that the efforts could cost between $6,500 and $22,000 per life year gained if herd immunity is considered. More than 70,000 cases, including 40 deaths, could be prevented. If only the benefits to the vaccinee are considered, the cost is an expensive $4 million per life year.

The incidence of pertussis has increased during the past few years, and public health officials have been looking for ways to rein it in. In the United States, the vaccine is only recommended for children.

The study was carried out on behalf of the Global Pertussis Initiative and funded by Aventis Pasteur.

Back to top


Clarification

This story also should have stated that Dr. Bisgard noted that the measles vaccine causes a very effective humoral immunity response and protects individuals from that disease.

Back to top


Copyright 2003 American Medical Association. All rights reserved.
 
Advertisement