Opinion 8.053 - Restrictions on Disclosure in Health Care Plan Contracts
Despite ethical requirements demanding full disclosure of treatment options regardless of limitations imposed by plan coverage, some health care plans include clauses in their employment contracts that directly inhibit the ability of physicians to keep their patients fully informed. These types of contract clauses erect inappropriate barriers to necessary communications between physicians and patients, labeled "gag clauses" by some observers. Restrictive clauses of this type impact the ability of physicians to provide information to their patients and to act effectively as a patient advocate. They also threaten to undermine individual and public trust in the profession of medicine.
(1) Health care plans have the right to protect proprietary information. However, physicians should oppose any such protection that inhibits them from disclosing relevant information to patients. For this reason, physicians should advocate for the elimination of contract clauses that could prevent them from raising or discussing matters relevant to patients’ medical care.
(2) The right of patients to be informed of all pertinent medical information must be reaffirmed by the medical profession, and individual physicians must continue to uphold their ethical obligation to disclose such information.
(3) Physicians, individually or through their representative, should review their contracts carefully to ensure that they are able to fulfill their ethical obligations to patients. (II, III, VI)